VMEDO_Anaesthesia Workstation

Comparing Boyle’s Apparatus and Anaesthesia Workstation

If you are looking to understand anaesthesia workstations and boyle’s apparatus, then you have come to the right place. To know more details about anaesthesia workstations and boyle’s apparatus, call us at +917406000610 or mail us at store@vmedo.com

For Comparing Boyle’s Apparatus and Anaesthesia Workstation, let us first understand the concept of Anaesthesia.

What is the meaning and the need for Anaesthesia?

Anaesthesia means a “loss of sensation”. It is the process of preventing a patient from feeling pain during invasive surgical procedures.

Anaesthesia can be in the form of 

  • Intravenous Injectable Liquid
  • Neuromuscular Injectable Liquid
  • Electric Shock
  • Inhalable Gas. 

Anaesthesia not only helps the patients to feel numb from pain but also helps the doctors and operating room staff to avoid the inconvenient movements of the patient due to pain caused during invasive surgical procedures.

What are the different types of Anaesthesia?

Anaesthesia is applied through the air inhalation process, intravenous or neuromuscular injection, or external electric stimulation. Based on the application of an anaesthesia to the area/part of the patient body, the types of anaesthesia are:

1. General Anaesthesia

General Anaesthesia makes the whole conscious body insensitive to external stimulation. The patient remains unconscious and is unable to move throughout the surgical procedure.

Application of General Anaesthesia:

It is used in major surgeries such as 

2. Regional Anaesthesia 

Regional Anaesthesia affects only the larger targeted part of the body such as arms, legs, or below the waist. Sometimes the patients need to be kept sedated during the application of regional anaesthesia.

Application of Regional Anaesthesia:

It is mainly used during 

3. Local Anaesthesia 

Local Anaesthesia affects only the smaller targeted part of the body. 

Application of Regional Anaesthesia:

It is employed in 

  • Dental Surgery
  • Superficial Dermatic Surgery
Source: The Lancet

Difference between Boyle’s Apparatus and Anaesthesia Workstation

Boyle’s Apparatus and Anaesthesia Workstation both employ air inhalation-based sedation procedures to keep the patient numb to the pain during surgical procedures.

Before understanding the comparative differences between Boyle’s apparatus and the Anaesthesia Workstation, let us understand how these apparatus work.

How does Boyle’s Apparatus work?

Boyle’s apparatus is a standard setup for combining the anaesthetic gases such as nitrous oxide, oxygen, and other sedative gases from their respective cylinders through perforated tubes in a mixing chamber, also referred to as a vaporizer. This vaporizer contains water and supplies the mixture of gases continuously to the patient lungs through the patient air circuit.

The implementation of the procedures to the patient, such as mechanical ventilation, patient monitoring, and external ventilation is possible to carry out during the time of functioning of the Boyle’s apparatus.

Boyle’s apparatus was developed and successfully used by Dr. Henry Boyle in 1917. Initially, this setup was known as Boyle’s bottle. Even to this day, Boyle’s apparatus is one of the most reliable basic anaesthesia set up in hospitals.

How does Anaesthesia Workstation work?

An anaesthesia workstation is a target-controlled system for sedating the patient by combining anaesthetic gases with oxygen from the cylinder/compressed storage system and supplying the mixture of these gases only based on the requirement to the patient lungs through an air circuit with the help of advanced electronic control systems.

The standout features of an Anaesthesia Workstation

Anaesthesia workstation offers integrated flowmeters, alarm system, patient monitoring advanced ventilation techniques, digital memory, and data management protocols. So anaesthesia workstation can be referred to as an improvised and advanced Boyle’s apparatus.

Anaesthesia workstation monitors the quantity of anaesthetic agents delivery, and monitors & controls low rate anaesthesia, circular anaesthesia, and ventilation tidal volumes. 

These protocols help the anaesthesiologists to properly deliver accurate tidal volumes of gases, maintain the patient safety and cost-effectiveness of the anaesthesia procedure.

Anaesthesia workstations are highly recommended for major surgeries such as Neuro and Spine surgeries, Organ Transplantation surgeries and Cardiac surgeries, as these surgical procedures require accurate and precise controlled delivery of the anaesthesia to the patient. Most importantly modern anaesthesia workstations employ alarm systems for indicating variations in the vital parameters of the patient and gas supply such as flow rate and tidal volume.

What are the main differences between Boyle’s Apparatus and Anaesthesia Workstation?

There are a few main differences between Boyle’s apparatus and Anaesthesia workstation and are listed below:

  1. Boyle’s apparatus frequently requires mechanical ventilation as there are no controlled ventilation systems implemented whereas Anaesthesia workstations are programmed to control the ventilation autonomously.
  2. As Boyle’s apparatus is a continuous gas supply system, the setup faces risk of leakage, internal parts misconnections and frequent failure of mechanical parts whereas Anaesthesia workstations are negligibly prone to such risks.
  3. Boyle’s apparatus needs continuous monitoring of the system function itself while Anaesthesia workstations have programmed alarms, digital memory and data management systems.
  4. Anaesthesia Workstations are safer and more reliable in major surgeries  compared to Boyle’s apparatus.
  5. Even though Anaesthesia workstations are more expensive than Boyle’s apparatus, they are proven to be more economically cost effective with reference to the recurring expenses of gas supply, repairs and man power associated with the Boyle’s apparatus.
  6. Anaesthesia workstations are more accurate and user friendly compared to Boyle’s apparatus.

Which one should you choose?

  • Boyle’s apparatus are best suited for single specialty hospitals, gynaecology setups with labour and operating rooms and temporary healthcare facilities such as health check-up camps. Boyle’s apparatus are less expensive and easy to handle.
  • Anaesthesia workstations are highly recommended in the multispeciality hospitals, institutions with specialities such as neurosurgery, cardiac surgeries, spine and orthopaedic surgeries and organ transplantation surgical procedures. Anaesthesia workstations require trained technicians to handle its operations, so there is a learning curve included in adopting the anaesthesia workstation. But operation of modern anaesthesia workstation is not so complex as the interfaces are very much intuitive and come with negligible annual maintenance.

Who are the best manufacturers and brands of Boyle’s Apparatus available in India?

Boyle’s apparatus is easy to operate and are less expensive, most Nursing homes, hospitals only with minor operating rooms and single-specialty hospitals will have the advantages with Boyle’s apparatus. There are many companies that supply Boyle’s apparatus to the hospitals in need, few of the best manufacturers and brands of Boyle’s Apparatus available in India are listed below:

Manufacturer Model
Medion Asteros Lite
Allied Medical Jupiter 200
  Jupiter 300
  Jupiter 500
Table 1: Manufacturers of Boyle’s Apparatus

Who are the best manufacturers and brands of Anaesthesia Workstations available in India?

Anaesthesia workstations are preferred by most of the Multispeciality hospitals today, so the manufacturers prefer to produce most of them as the availability of electronics and software are feasible today. Few of the best manufacturers and brands of Anaesthesia Workstations available in India are listed below:

Manufacturer Model
Draeger Fabius Plus
BPL  EFLO 6
  EFLO 6C
  EFLO 6D
  EFLO 7
  Penlon Prima 320
Aeonmed Aeon 7200 A
  Aeon 8300 A
Medion Asteros Royale Vent VII
  Asteros Royale Vent VIII
  Asteros Royale Vent X
Table 2: Manufacturers of Anaesthesia Workstation

Few of the best manufacturers and brands of Anaesthesia Vapouriser and Ventilators available in India are: 

  • BPL Penlon Sigma Delta Vapouriser
  • Medion Vapourizer
  • Jupiter Vapouriser
  • Alveonic AVS 180 Anaesthesia Ventilator

Suppliers of the best manufacturers and brands of Boyle’s Apparatus and Anaesthesia Workstations available in India

If you are looking for a reliable supplier who you can trust throughout your buying process for the best manufacturers and brands of Boyle’s Apparatus and Anaesthesia Workstations available in India, look no other way and contact VMEDO Store now. We are currently serving across all cities of India and mainly in Karnataka.

  1. Bengaluru
  2. Delhi
  3. Mumbai
  4. Pune
  5. Chennai
  6. Hyderabad
  7. Tumkur
  8. Shivamogga (Shimoga)
  9. Davangere
  10. Mysuru (Mysore)
  11. Mandya
  12. Madikeri
  13. Chamarajanagar
  14. Hubballi
  15. Gadag
  16. Haveri
  17. Uttara Kannada

Contact us at +917406000610 or mail us at store@vmedo.com

VMEDO is an Emergency Healthcare Ecosystem where we are working towards saving more lives by assisting people to book Ambulances, medical equipment, and healthcare training programs on one single platform. We pride ourselves in being one of India’s largest Ambulance networks and have helped over 1,00,000 people in emergencies. We have empowered more than 10,000 Professionals with First Aid Skills. Through VMEDO Store, we have supplied over 1 Million+ medical equipment and surgical supplies across India.

Related Posts